Experts CornerExperts CornerPaid Contribution

Paid for by Axipro. ITSPmagazine reviews every Experts Corner piece before it runs. The views are the author’s own.

Is Vanta or Drata Enough? Why Green Dashboards Still Fail Audits

Is Vanta or Drata Enough? Why Green Dashboards Still Fail Audits

Vanta tells buyers it can automate up to 80% of the work it takes to get ISO 27001 certified (Vanta, n.d.-a). That figure is probably fair. What we see with SaaS clients is that the integrations get connected in the first week, the dashboard goes mostly green, and leadership starts talking about the audit as if it were a formality. A few months later the project is still “nearly ready.” It almost always stalls in the remaining 20%, which, unhelpfully, is the part the auditor forms an opinion on.

Is Vanta or Drata enough on its own?

Vanta or Drata on its own is enough to collect SOC 2 and ISO 27001 evidence, but for most companies going through a first audit it won’t be enough to pass. The platform handles the integrations and the monitoring. Someone at the company still has to set the scope, make the risk calls, rewrite the policies so they match how the business really runs, and get the flagged issues fixed. That remaining 20% of the work is what the auditor signs off on.

What compliance automation does well

Compliance automation platforms like Vanta and Drata are very good at the repetitive half of compliance. They plug into AWS, Google Workspace, GitHub and the HR system, and check every day that MFA is switched on, laptops are encrypted and people who left the company no longer have access. The policy templates give you a starting point, and the auditor portals save a lot of back-and-forth once the audit begins. For a 20-person startup without a security hire, that’s a big improvement, and it’s the reason we set these platforms up for most of our clients.

Why a green dashboard can still fail an audit

A green dashboard can still fail an audit because it only reports on what it was connected to and set up to test, while the auditor looks at everything in scope. James Preamble of Schneider Downs puts it well: integrations are only as reliable as their scoping, and a missing cloud account, an excluded code repository or an incomplete user list can leave a platform showing coverage it doesn’t actually have (Preamble, 2026). A passing check on the systems the platform can see tells you nothing about the ones it can’t.

Most of the other failures trace back to decisions nobody made. Which products and environments are in scope? How are risks rated? Which template controls describe how the team actually works, and which were just left switched on? Then there are access reviews, where the platform logs that the review task was done but the auditor wants each reviewer’s decision and proof that flagged access was removed (Dias, 2026). And when the monitor does flag a problem, an engineer still has to go and fix it.

Axipro spends most of its time on this part of the job. Axipro is a compliance readiness and cybersecurity consultancy, a Drata Elite Partner and Drata’s top partner in EMEA, and it also implements Vanta for SaaS and technology companies working toward SOC 2, ISO 27001 and ISO 42001. Across more than 300 certified clients the pattern has held up well: the integrations take days, and getting scope, risk and policies signed off takes weeks.

Pro Tip: Before fieldwork, export the list of accounts, repositories and user populations each integration covers and check it line by line against the system description you’re giving the auditor. Anything in the system description that the integrations don’t cover is a likely exception in a Type 2 report.

Why “Vanta or Drata?” is the wrong first question

Choosing between Vanta and Drata is the wrong place to start, because both will collect the same evidence for a scope you haven’t defined yet. Plenty of founders spend weeks on the Drata vs Vanta comparison, sign, and then find the hard decisions still waiting for them. Bill Bodner of EisnerAmper puts numbers on it: a lot of business owners think spending $10,000 to $15,000 on a tool that gets them 80% of the way there is a good deal, when the remaining 20% is the hardest part to finish (Bodner, 2023). He also points out that buyers wrongly expect the software to cut the time or cost of the audit itself, even though every audit firm still runs its own procedures. So pick whichever platform your auditor and engineers are comfortable with, and spend the real effort on scope.

When you need a consultant, and when you don’t

You need a consultant alongside Vanta or Drata when nobody in the company owns compliance as part of their actual job, or when a deal deadline means you can’t afford to fail the first attempt. Engineering time is usually what runs out. In a July 2026 Pentest-Tools.com survey of 201 security and compliance practitioners, 50.7% said getting time and input from technical teams was their biggest audit preparation bottleneck, and only 3.5% said they had no significant bottleneck at all (Pentest-Tools.com, 2026). Buying a platform doesn’t give your engineers more hours. In our experience, these are the signs that you need outside help:

  • No one in-house has taken a company through a SOC 2 or ISO 27001 audit before.
  • An enterprise customer has put a date on when they need your report.
  • You’re pursuing more than one framework at once, such as SOC 2 and ISO 27001.
  • The dashboard has said “nearly ready” for more than a quarter.

If none of those apply, a platform and a capable internal owner is often enough, and the money you’d spend on a consultant to watch over a program that already works is probably better spent somewhere else.

The AI agent makes ownership more urgent

AI features in compliance platforms make it more important to have a named owner. Drata now uses AI to summarize what went wrong when a control test fails, and Vanta markets agentic workflows that handle evidence, policies and remediation (Drata, n.d.; Vanta, n.d.-b). That speeds up the paperwork. It also makes it easy for a policy to go from draft to approved to uploaded without anyone reading it closely. The auditor will still sit down with your staff and ask how access reviews and incident response work in practice, and a well-written policy that nobody follows is still a finding.

Buy the platform, then name an owner

Vanta or Drata is enough to end the screenshot scramble, and for most SaaS companies it’s the right thing to buy. What it won’t give you is an audit plan. Before you sign, decide who owns scope, risk decisions and remediation, whether that’s someone you hire or an outside partner, and make sure they have the authority to pull engineers onto fixes. The dashboard can tell you the integrations are working. Whether that means you’re ready for the auditor is that person’s call.

References

Bodner, B. (2023, March 17). How to compare automated security and compliance software tools versus a SOC 2 audit approach. EisnerAmper. https://www.eisneramper.com/insights/soc-services/automated-security-compliance-software-tools-vs-soc2-audit-0323/

Dias, P. (2026, August 11). 4 SOC 2 controls auditors reject even when your compliance tool says passing. Axipro. https://axipro.co/soc-2-controls-auditors-reject/

Drata. (n.d.). ISO 42001. Drata. https://drata.com/frameworks/iso-42001

Pentest-Tools.com. (2026). Compliance audit cycles: What 201 practitioners experience. Pentest-Tools.com. https://pentest-tools.com/insights/compliance-cycles-survey

Preamble, J. (2026, May 15). Don’t mistake evidence collection for audit integrity: What compliance automation can’t tell you. Schneider Downs. https://schneiderdowns.com/our-thoughts-on/what-compliance-automation-cant-tell-you/

Vanta. (n.d.-a). Key benefits of automating ISO 27001 compliance. Vanta. https://www.vanta.com/collection/iso-27001/benefits-of-compliance-automation-iso-27001

Vanta. (n.d.-b). ISO 42001. Vanta. https://www.vanta.com/products/iso-42001

From Axipro
Learn more about Drata
axipro.co
i
Experts Corner

Have an expert opinion to share on ITSPmagazine? Learn more about Experts Corner →

Ali Hayat

About the expert

Ali Hayat

CEO, Axipro

Ali Hayat is the founder and CEO of Axipro, a compliance and cybersecurity consultancy with
offices in Bahrain, the UK and the US. A former senior auditor, he holds lead qualifications in
ISO 27001 and ISO 42001 and has helped technology companies prepare for SOC 2, ISO
27001 and ISO 42001 audits.

More from Ali →

Connect →

Axipro logo

About the company

Axipro

SOC 2 compliance consultants for startups and SMBs

Axipro is a SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, ISO 42001, AIUC-1, compliance consultant for startups and SMBs in the Gulf region, Singapore, Europe, United States, and Australia.

Visit →